While learning about Robert Frank's American photography, I found out that Walker Evans, an American photographer influenced him to pursue that project. He was also a photojournalist. Evans is best known for his documentation of the Great Depression. The image above is "Alabama Tenant Farmer Family singing Hymns" (1936). This was taken towards the end of the depression, in the Southern U.S.
The title describes the picture exactly. There is a family singing hymns. The father is holding the book and the children are following his cue. While non of them are poorly dressed, they aren't formally dressed either. The boys' hair is a little shaggy. Lots of wrinkles in everyone's clothes. These details help the picture provide more exposition.
The choice of backdrop, the side paneling of a house, adds scale to the image. Each child reaches a different height in the paneling, and the father towers above. It adds a sense of measure to the gradient established by having them stand in order from shortest to tallest. The expression in their faces while singing also shows each one's character. The father is stolid. The daughter attempts maturity. One son seems uncertain. And the shortest boy is overcompensating by appearing to sing the loudest, something his aggressively opened mouth leads me to believe he is doing.
Ultimately, its the positioning of the family and the details of them that made this a strong picture for me. The way they look, how they behave, it gave the picture it's feeling of a tired hope. They don't look particularly happy, and how could they given the time this was taken, but they don't look defeated. And the singing cues that they're biding for a better time.
